Cincinnati 3-4-1-2New York City 4-2-3-1R. Celentano18A. Powell
2N. Hagglund4M. Miazga21L. Engel29B. Smith
14P. Bucha20E. da Silva Ferreira10B. Anunga
27E. Echenique Peña66A. Denkey9F. Matthew49T. Gray24T. Martins Bueno13J. Haak80K. O'Toole
22M. Moralez
10A. O'Neill21A. Perea Castañeda
8H. Wolf
17A. Martínez Batista
16N. Fernández Mercau
7| Nicolás Fernández Mercau | 29' | ![]() | ||
| out: A. Perea Jonathan Shore | 43' | ![]() | ||
![]() | 46' | Kenji Mboma Dem out: Brad Smith | ||
| Assist: Maxi Moralez Alonso Martínez 0-1 | 55' | ![]() | ||
| out: Hannes Wolf Agustín Ojeda | 61' | ![]() | ||
| Agustín Ojeda | 63' | ![]() | ||
![]() | 70' | Kei Kamara out: Alvas Powell | ||
![]() | 71' | Gerardo Valenzuela out: Tah Anunga | ||
| out: Maxi Moralez Julián Fernández | 81' | ![]() | ||
![]() | 82' | Yuya Kubo out: Kenji Mboma Dem | ||
| Kevin O'Toole | 89' | ![]() | ||
Lineups

Cincinnati
![]() | 18R. Celentano Goalkeeper |
![]() | 2A. Powell 70'Midfielder |
![]() | 4N. Hagglund Dedender |
![]() | 21M. Miazga Dedender |
![]() | 29L. Engel Dedender |
![]() | 14B. Smith 46'Midfielder |
![]() | 20P. Bucha Midfielder |
![]() | 10E. da Silva Ferreira Forward |
![]() | 27B. Anunga 71'Midfielder |
![]() | 66E. Echenique Peña Forward |
![]() | 9A. Denkey Forward |

New York City
![]() | 49F. Matthew Goalkeeper |
![]() | 24T. Gray Dedender |
![]() | 13T. Martins Bueno Dedender |
![]() | 80J. Haak Dedender |
![]() | 22K. O'Toole 89'Dedender |
![]() | 10M. Moralez 81'Midfielder |
![]() | 21A. O'Neill Midfielder |
![]() | 8A. Perea Castañeda 43'Midfielder |
![]() | 17H. Wolf 61'Midfielder |
![]() | 16A. Martínez Batista 55'Forward |
![]() | 7N. Fernández Mercau 29'Midfielder |
Substitutes

Cincinnati
![]() | 13E. Louro Goalkeeper |
![]() | 16T. Hadebe Dedender |
![]() | 3G. Flores Melgarejo Dedender |
![]() | 35K. Mboma Dem 46' 82'Forward |
![]() | 37S. Jimenez Midfielder |
![]() | 85K. Kamara 70'Forward |
![]() | 7Y. Kubo 82'Forward |
![]() | 19S. Chirila Midfielder |
![]() | 22G. Valenzuela 71'Midfielder |

New York City
![]() | 30T. Romero Keubler Goalkeeper |
![]() | 12S. Tanasijević Dedender |
![]() | 35M. Ilenčič Dedender |
![]() | 38A. Baiera Dedender |
![]() | 26A. Ojeda 61' 63'Forward |
![]() | 32J. Shore 43'Midfielder |
![]() | 29M. Carrizo Ballesteros Midfielder |
![]() | 11J. Fernández 81'Forward |
![]() | 99S. Garfield-Reid Forward |






































