New York City 3-4-1-2Columbus Crew 3-4-2-1L. Barraza1J. Haak80J. Sands6A. Alfaro
93M. Ilenčič
35A. Morales
7K. Alexander Parks
55B. Cufré
3S. Rodríguez Molina
10G. Pereira dos Santos11T. Bacelar Martins
43P. Schulte28S. Zawadzki25S. Moreira31M. Amundsen18M. Farsi23D. Nagbe6A. Morris8Y. Yeboah
14C. Ramírez
17A. Măţan
20J. Hernández Suárez9![]() | 32' | Braian Cufré | ||
| Assist: Alexandru Matan Christian Ramirez 0-1 | 48' | ![]() | ||
![]() | 59' | Richard Ledezma out: Alfredo Morales | ||
![]() | 73' | G. Segal out: Tony Alfaro | ||
![]() | 73' | Tayvon Gray out: Talles Magno | ||
| out: Alexandru Matan I. Parente | 73' | ![]() | ||
| out: Yaw Yeboah M. Arfsten | 76' | ![]() | ||
![]() | 78' | K. O'Toole out: Braian Cufré | ||
![]() | 78' | S. Turnbull out: M. Ilenčič | ||
| out: Christian Ramirez J. Russell-Rowe | 81' | ![]() | ||
![]() | 90' | Keaton Parks | ||
![]() | 90+4' | 1-1 G. Segal | ||
![]() | 90+6' | S. Rodríguez | ||
![]() | 90+6' | |||
Lineups

New York City
![]() | 1L. Barraza Goalkeeper |
![]() | 80J. Haak Dedender |
![]() | 6J. Sands Dedender |
![]() | 93A. Alfaro 73'Dedender |
![]() | 35M. Ilenčič 78'Midfielder |
![]() | 7A. Morales 59'Midfielder |
![]() | 55K. Alexander Parks 90'Midfielder |
![]() | 3B. Cufré 32' 78'Midfielder |
![]() | 10S. Rodríguez Molina 90'+6Forward |
![]() | 11G. Pereira dos Santos Forward |
![]() | 43T. Bacelar Martins 73'Forward |

Columbus Crew
![]() | 28P. Schulte Goalkeeper |
![]() | 25S. Zawadzki Dedender |
![]() | 31S. Moreira Dedender |
![]() | 18M. Amundsen Dedender |
![]() | 23M. Farsi Midfielder |
![]() | 6D. Nagbe Midfielder |
![]() | 8A. Morris Midfielder |
![]() | 14Y. Yeboah 76'Midfielder |
![]() | 17C. Ramírez 48' 81'Forward |
![]() | 20A. Măţan 73'Forward |
![]() | 9J. Hernández Suárez Forward |
Substitutes

New York City
![]() | 49F. Matthew Goalkeeper |
![]() | 24T. Gray 73'Dedender |
![]() | 33N. Benalcazar Dedender |
![]() | 34S. Turnbull 78'Dedender |
![]() | 22K. O'Toole 78'Forward |
![]() | 21A. Jasson Midfielder |
![]() | 17M. Pellegrini Forward |
![]() | 20R. Ledezma 59'Midfielder |
![]() | 19G. Segal 73' 90'+4Forward |

Columbus Crew
![]() | 24E. Bush Goalkeeper |
![]() | 2P. Quinton Dedender |
![]() | 22K. Hughes Dedender |
![]() | 94J. Medranda Obando Dedender |
![]() | 33J. Morris Midfielder |
![]() | 16I. Parente 73'Midfielder |
![]() | 19J. Russell-Rowe 81'Forward |
![]() | 27M. Arfsten 76'Forward |









































