Columbus Crew
1 - 0
Atlanta United
0-0
D
2-2
D
0-0
D
1-1
D
2-2
D
1-2
L
0-0
D
1-2
L
2-2
D
1-1
D
Half time: 1 - 0
Elapsed: FT
Kick off: 19:00 UTC
Date: Sat 24-Feb-24
Wheater: clear sky
 |  |  | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Columbus Crew | 3 | 0 | 0 | 1 |
| Atlanta United | 2 | 2 | 0 | 0 |
Columbus Crew 3-4-2-1Atlanta United 4-2-3-1P. Schulte28R. Camacho4M. Amundsen18M. Farsi
23D. Nagbe6Y. Yeboah14S. Zawadzki25A. Morris8D. Rossi Marachlian10J. Hernández Suárez9J. Russell-Rowe19B. Guzan1D. Williams3S. Rode Gregersen5B. Lennon11C. Wiley26S. Lobzhanidze9A. Costa Silva16T. Muyumba Nkita8B. Slisz6T. Almada10G. Giakoumakis7| Georgios Giakoumakis | 21' | | ||
| 27' | 1-0 Cucho Hernández Assist: Diego Rossi | ||
 | 51' | Maximilian Arfsten out: Mohamed Farsi | ||
| 52' | ||||
| Stian Gregersen | 53' | | ||
 | 54' | Cucho Hernández | ||
| 75' | Alexandru Mățan out: Jacen Russell-Rowe | ||
| out: Xande Silva Tyler Wolff | 81' | | ||
| out: Tristan Muyumba Ajani Fortune | 81' | | ||
| 88' | Steven Moreira out: Yaw Yeboah | ||
Lineups
Columbus Crew
 | 28P. Schulte Goalkeeper |
 | 4R. Camacho Dedender |
 | 18M. Amundsen Dedender |
 | 23M. Farsi51'52' Midfielder |
 | 6D. Nagbe Midfielder |
 | 14Y. Yeboah88' Midfielder |
 | 25S. Zawadzki Dedender |
 | 8A. Morris Midfielder |
 | 10D. Rossi Marachlian Forward |
 | 9J. Hernández Suárez27'54' Forward |
 | 19J. Russell-Rowe75' Forward |
Atlanta United
 | 1B. Guzan Goalkeeper |
 | 3D. Williams Dedender |
 | 5S. Rode Gregersen53' Dedender |
 | 11B. Lennon Dedender |
 | 26C. Wiley Dedender |
 | 9S. Lobzhanidze Midfielder |
 | 16A. Costa Silva81' Midfielder |
 | 8T. Muyumba Nkita81' Midfielder |
 | 6B. Slisz Midfielder |
 | 10T. Almada Midfielder |
 | 7G. Giakoumakis21' Forward |
Substitutes
Columbus Crew
 | 27M. Arfsten51' Forward |
 | 31S. Moreira88' Dedender |
 | 2P. Quinton Dedender |
 | 17C. Ramírez Forward |
 | 24E. Bush Goalkeeper |
 | 20A. Măţan75' Midfielder |
 | 21Y. Cheberko Dedender |
 | 5D. Jones Midfielder |
 | 11M. Hinestroza Angulo Forward |
Atlanta United
 | 35A. Fortune81' Midfielder |
 | 30E. Firmino Midfielder |
 | 28T. Wolff81' Forward |
 | 24N. Cobb Dedender |
 | 4L. Abram Ugarelli Dedender |
 | 22J. Cohen Goalkeeper |
 | 13D. McCarty Midfielder |
 | 2R. Hernández Pimentel Dedender |
| 25L. Brennan Midfielder |